A NSW review into strata insurance commissions has opened a strong debate that’s been avoided for years. Here’s what’s actually being proposed, and why the answer affects every strata owner in Australia.
Behind strata insurance sits a remuneration arrangement that a growing number of regulators, consumer advocates and industry bodies think deserves far more transparency than it currently gets.
The NSW Productivity and Equality Commission have released its review into how strata managers are paid, with four reform options now on the table. The debate about which path NSW takes has real effects on owners, managers and the professionals who arrange their insurance.
What the NSW review into strata commissions actually found
The review’s core concern is straightforward: when a strata manager receives a commission from an insurer for placing a building’s insurance, they profit from a recommendation they’re also responsible for making. That’s a conflict of interest and one that owners have historically had little visibility over.
The Commission found that moving from a commission-based model to a fee-for-service model could simplify remuneration structures, improve competition and service quality, increase trust, and lower costs – generating more than $300 million in net benefits for NSW over 15 years.
Four options were put forward, ranging from phasing out insurance commissions specifically to prohibiting all commissions, with one option permitting a regulated flat fee in place of percentage-based arrangements.
The direction of travel is clear. What remains genuinely unsettled is where the boundaries of any reform should sit and whether insurance brokers should be caught inside them.
Where brokers enter the picture and why it matters
Here’s where the reform gets contested.
The NSW Productivity and Equality Commission’s recommendation two proposes restricting commission-based pay for insurance brokers providing strata-related services, not just strata managers. That’s a meaningful extension and it’s one the National Insurance Brokers Association (NIBA) has pushed back on firmly.
The core of NIBA’s argument is a regulatory distinction that the reform, as drafted, risks obscuring: strata managers and insurance brokers are not the same kind of entity, and grouping them together as “supply chain intermediaries” misrepresents how brokers actually operate.
NIBA says brokers are not supply chain intermediaries but licensed financial services professionals subject to Australian Securities and Investments Commission oversight and the Insurance Brokers Code of Practice, with legal duties to act in clients’ best interests.
That’s not a minor technical point; it goes to the heart of what a broker is actually for.
The difference between a strata manager and a strata insurance broker
A strata manager arranges insurance as part of managing a scheme. Their primary role is operational: maintaining records, coordinating services, managing the day-to-day. When they receive a commission from an insurer for placing business, there’s a legitimate question about whose interest is being served.
A strata insurance broker is a different thing entirely. They hold an Australian Financial Services Licence, they operate under ASIC oversight and are legally obligated to act in the client’s best interest (not the insurer’s or the strata manager’s). Their job is advice, not administration.
Removing commission as a remuneration mechanism for brokers doesn’t eliminate their cost, it shifts it. For smaller strata schemes, a separate advice fee may simply mean no professional advice at all.
What the data says about what brokers actually deliver
The case for brokers isn’t just theoretical. Survey data from NIBA points to measurable outcomes for strata communities that use professional brokers.
98% of respondents reported claims successfully resolved and 91% said brokers helped achieve better business outcomes. As well, 84% trusted their broker to act in their best interest. That’s the data doing the talking.
None of that means commissions are beyond scrutiny. But it does suggest that the question isn’t simply whether commissions exist, it’s whether the professional receiving them is actually delivering independent value in return.
Where things stand now
SCA NSW committed from 1 January 2026 to phasing out insurance commissions among its members, with new standard management contracts no longer including the option to accept commissions on insurance products. That voluntary move pre-empts whatever the government ultimately legislates and signals that the industry broadly accepts the direction, even if the details remain contested.
The NSW Government is now considering the Commission’s findings. No legislation has yet passed and the four options remain on the table, with the question remaining of how brokers fit into the final framework.
For strata owners and committees, the practical message is this: the reform is coming. Understanding what it covers and what it doesn’t, will matter for how you arrange insurance, who you work with and what you pay.
Frequently asked questions about strata insurance commissions
What are strata insurance commissions? Strata insurance commissions are payments made to strata managers by insurers or brokers for arranging insurance on behalf of an owners corporation. They have long been criticised for creating conflicts of interest, since the person recommending the insurance also profits from the placement.
Is the NSW strata insurance commission ban confirmed? Not yet. The NSW Productivity and Equality Commission handed down its report in February 2026 with four reform options. The NSW Government is currently considering which approach to legislate. SCA NSW members have already begun transitioning away from commissions voluntarily.
What happens to strata insurance advice if commissions are banned for brokers? NIBA has raised concern that removing commission as a remuneration mechanism may lead owners to forgo professional advice altogether, particularly in smaller schemes where paying a separate advice fee is impractical. How the government resolves this tension will be central to the final legislation.
